GAO finds military records offices released personal data improperly and missed deadlines amid staff gaps
A covert GAO test of 26 records requests drew one improper Army release and eight unanswered requests. The services reported 49 breaches affecting more than 1,000 service members in five years, and the Navy's FOIA office was down to one employee.
Posing as a private attorney or another outside requester, Government Accountability Office investigators sent 26 requests for service members’ records to the military; the Army approved a flawed request and released information that should have been redacted[1].
The report, released Oct. 16, answers a request in the House Armed Services Committee’s report on the fiscal 2024 defense authorization bill to review how the Pentagon releases service members’ records[1]. Those files decide a great deal after discharge. Personnel records follow veterans into benefits claims, background checks and medical referrals, and the custodians include the Defense Department, each military service, the Department of Veterans Affairs, the National Archives and more than 500 military hospitals and clinics[1]. GAO found that the offices doing the work are short-staffed, slow in places and, in a small share of cases, careless with Social Security numbers and other personal data[1].
What GAO’s covert test found
Investigators submitted three Privacy Act requests and two Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) requests to each of the five services, plus one extra request to the Space Force after a member it had targeted transferred to the Army[1]. Some forms carried deliberate errors that, GAO was told, the services use as checks to validate a request; those should have triggered a denial or a request for more information[1].
The results over the 90-day test:
| Outcome | Requests |
|---|---|
| Approved, appropriately (Marine Corps FOIA requests with no flaws) | 2 |
| Approved improperly (Army, flawed request; unredacted personal data released) | 1 |
| Denied because of deliberate flaws | 3 |
| Response with no decision, or no response | 20 |
Source: GAO-27-107784[1].
On timing, 18 of the 26 drew a response within the 20-day window[1]. For the other eight, GAO received no decision, no acknowledgment of receipt and no request for more information[1]. FOIA requires an agency to decide within 20 days, not counting weekends and federal holidays, whether it will comply[2].
How many military records breaches were reported?
From fiscal 2021 through 2025, the services’ personnel centers processed more than 390,000 FOIA and Privacy Act requests and reported 49 breaches involving the improper release of personally identifiable information[1]. GAO said those breaches affected more than 1,000 service members[1].
| Service | Reported breaches, FY2021–2025 |
|---|---|
| Air Force (includes Space Force) | 24 |
| Navy | 17 |
| Army | 8 |
| Marine Corps | 0 |
Source: GAO analysis of Defense Privacy Information Management System data[1].
Navy officials told GAO that 15 of its 17 involved personal data sent by unsecure email rather than mistakes in answering a records request[1]. Across all services, 44 of the 49 were attributed to human error or failure to follow policy, and officials said reviews and redactions are still done by hand, without software to find and strip protected information from long files[1].
After learning of an improper release in October 2022, the Air Force Personnel Center audited third-party requests from 2021 through 2023 and found the records of 11 people, including two members of Congress and several congressional candidates, had gone out without proper authority, some of it related to a sexual assault[1]. The Air Force then added a second reviewer to check redactions[1]. In March 2023, House Armed Services Chairman Mike Rogers, R-Ala., and House Oversight Chairman James Comer, R-Ky., said the Pentagon had answered their questions only for the Department of the Air Force and had not said what happened to the people involved[7]. “The Department of Defense failed to protect the private information of our servicemembers,” they said[7].
GAO also cited a 2024 allegation that VA employees viewed vice-presidential candidates’ health records without authorization, and a June 2025 case in which the National Personnel Records Center, part of the National Archives, released a member of Congress’s full record, including Social Security number and date of birth, when only FOIA-releasable information should have gone out[1]. Army officials told GAO that election years bring more requests from the media and the public for the records of candidates[1].
The Pentagon’s objection
The Defense Department concurred with all five recommendations but disputed parts of the report[1]. It said the 49 breaches were counted without applying the federal risk-of-harm framework, and that more than 90% were low-risk administrative errors that did not harm anyone[1]. It said the report mixed general administrative incidents with breaches from the FOIA and Privacy Act release process, which it said mischaracterizes its security posture[1]. It also objected that GAO described records management as fragmented while leaving out the oversight role of the department’s Director of Administration and Management[1].
GAO responded that the law requires all breaches to be reported regardless of risk, that it did not analyze each incident’s risk and so could not verify the 90% figure, and that the oversight offices generally do not make individual release decisions[1]. It also stood by using the services’ own data rather than the department’s annual FOIA reports to the Justice Department, which it said do not break out third-party requests by service[1].
One-person offices and growing backlogs
GAO tied both the errors and the delays to staffing[1]. Its findings by service:
- Navy. All Navy Personnel Command FOIA requests were handled by one federal civilian employee after a senior colleague retired[1]. Average processing time rose from 1.64 days in fiscal 2018 to 55.5 days in fiscal 2024 and 77.4 days as of July 2025[1]. The Navy faced four lawsuits in 2025 over third-party requests, hired an assistant in late December 2025 and, as of April 2026, had a backlog reduction plan using the two employees plus reservists[1]. Its Privacy Act workload reached 120,917 requests in fiscal 2024, with a reported backlog of 16,034[1].
- Army. The personnel center had 16 unfilled positions in March 2025, and its FOIA backlog went from 14 in fiscal 2023 to 96 by July 2025[1]. In March 2026, Army officials said a reorganization that centralized FOIA intake and automated routing had improved timeliness and accuracy without new hires[1].
- Marine Corps. An official said in September 2026 that the FOIA backlog stood at 75 because an administrative vacancy could not be filled[1].
- Air Force. One attorney reviews all nongovernmental requests after three civilian attorneys left under the Pentagon’s Deferred Resignation Program, and the Privacy Act backlog grew from 165 in fiscal 2018 to 623 in July 2025[1].
Officials across the department told GAO that FOIA and Privacy Act offices are often a low staffing priority, and that civilian workforce cuts and hiring freezes since early 2025 made vacancies harder to fill[1]. The Pentagon spent nearly $500 million processing more than 266,000 FOIA requests in fiscal 2020 through 2024, including $21 million on FOIA litigation[1].
Why health records take longer
The Defense Health Agency (DHA) handles health record requests for 9.5 million service members, retirees and family members at 547 medical facilities[1]. No single system holds a complete record, so processors search MHS Genesis, the Pentagon’s current electronic health record, along with older systems and paper files[1]. Records for people who separated or retired after Jan. 1, 2014, were digitized; older records may still be on paper[1]. One official estimated that about 40% of a person’s record is available through the MHS Genesis patient portal[1]. One facility told GAO a request of about 10,000 pages took about six days to complete[1].
From 2019 through September 2025, DHA reported about 7,332 breaches of health or other personal information, 84 of them tied to third-party requests[1]. DHA’s digital strategy, which includes artificial intelligence tools that could speed processing, is expected to be fully in place sometime in 2029[1].
GAO recommended that the Army align its recent functional review with a workforce planning analysis, that the Navy, Marine Corps and Air Force each conduct one, and that DHA assess its health records request systems as part of a study of its “health informatics” business function[1]. Separately, a Pentagon policy on hiring and training privacy staff, answering a 2022 GAO recommendation, is expected to be final by March 2027, according to a defense official[1].
The report does not take up the separate question of how records move to VA at discharge, the subject of a September executive order this site covered in its report on the order’s deadlines.
If you’re affected
- Getting your own records. Veterans and next of kin can request a DD Form 214 and other personnel and medical records from the National Archives’ National Personnel Records Center online through eVetRecs, which requires identity verification, or by mail or fax with Standard Form 180[5, 6]. Basic copies are generally free when the discharge was less than 62 years ago; some private companies charge for the same service[5].
- Timing. The center receives about 4,000 to 5,000 requests a day and asks requesters not to send a follow-up before 90 days have passed[5]. For an urgent need such as surgery or a funeral, select Emergency Request in the online request or note the emergency on the SF-180 and fax it to 314-801-0764; customer service is 314-801-0800[6]. Burial requests for a VA national cemetery go to the National Cemetery Scheduling Office at 800-535-1117[6].
- Who else can see your file. Under the Privacy Act, an agency generally may not release a record without the person’s written request or prior written consent unless a statutory exception applies[3]. The public can obtain only limited information from files of people who left service less than 62 years ago[5].
- Health records. A covered health care provider must act on a request for access within 30 days and may take a single 30-day extension if it gives written reasons and a completion date[4].
- Questions about the report go to Kristy Williams, GAO’s director for defense capabilities and management, at williamsk@gao.gov[1].
Readers ask
- How do veterans request a copy of their DD 214?
- Through the National Archives’ National Personnel Records Center, either online through eVetRecs, which requires identity verification, or by mailing or faxing a Standard Form 180[5, 6]. Basic personnel and medical record copies are generally free for veterans and next of kin when the discharge was less than 62 years ago[5].
- How long does the military have to answer a FOIA request for service records?
- Federal law gives agencies 20 working days to decide whether to comply with a FOIA request[2]. GAO found the Navy’s personnel FOIA office averaged 55.5 days in fiscal 2024 and 77.4 days as of July 2025[1].
- Can someone else get my military records without my permission?
- Generally not. The Privacy Act bars agencies from disclosing a record without the individual’s written request or prior written consent unless a listed exception applies, and the public can see only limited information from files of people who left service less than 62 years ago[3, 5].
- How long does a military hospital have to send me my medical records?
- Under HIPAA rules, a covered entity must act on an access request within 30 days and may take one 30-day extension if it explains the delay in writing[4]. GAO said Defense Health Agency facilities must meet that standard[1].
- What happens next on the GAO recommendations?
- The Defense Department concurred with all five recommendations, which call for staffing analyses at each service’s personnel records office and a review of how the Defense Health Agency processes health record requests[1]. GAO lists them as open until it confirms action[1].
Sources
- Service Member Records: DOD Needs to Address Improper and Delayed Releasing of Personnel and Health Information (GAO-27-107784). U.S. Government Accountability Office, October 16, 2026.
- 5 U.S. Code § 552 - Public information; agency rules, opinions, orders, records, and proceedings. U.S. Congress, accessed 2026-11-10.
- 5 U.S. Code § 552a - Records maintained on individuals. U.S. Congress, accessed 2026-11-10.
- 45 CFR § 164.524 - Access of individuals to protected health information. U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, accessed 2026-11-10.
- Request Military Service Records. National Archives and Records Administration, accessed 2026-11-10.
- Request Military Personnel Records Using Standard Form 180. National Archives and Records Administration, accessed 2026-11-10.
- Rogers, Comer Statement on DoD Response to Mishandling of Servicemember Records. House Armed Services Committee, March 17, 2023.
A note on sourcing
The request, backlog and breach figures in this story were reported by the military services and the Defense Health Agency; GAO says it could not independently determine their reliability, and the services did not supply complete fiscal 2025 data. GAO’s covert test of 26 requests is nongeneralizable and was not designed to establish why requests were delayed. The breach counts are self-reported and, according to GAO, may understate the number of incidents; the Pentagon says more than 90% were low-risk administrative errors, a characterization GAO did not independently check. The 2024 allegation that VA employees viewed vice-presidential candidates’ health records is described by GAO as an allegation. The Army’s March 2026 account that a reorganization has improved timeliness and accuracy comes from Army officials and was not tested by GAO. This story does not draw on comment from the individual military services beyond what GAO reported, or from veterans service organizations.
Filed undermilitary records · privacy · GAO · FOIA · Defense Health Agency · National Archives
Return to THE FRONT PAGE