Skip to the stories

Edition of

Federal AffairsDispatch

Vol. I · No. 46Online edition

Veterans, service members and military families: the federal decisions that reach them.

BenefitsCongress

VA inspector general finds errors in about a third of disability compensation reductions

A review of 2024 cases found faulty due process letters, wrong effective dates and proposed cuts that were never finished, leaving at least $16.9 million in underpayments and overpayments. VA agreed to fix the process.

The Department of Veterans Affairs made errors in about a third of the cases in which it moved to cut or end veterans’ disability compensation in 2024, the department’s inspector general reported Aug. 31, leaving at least $16.9 million paid out wrongly[1].

The review, report No. 25-01011-154, looked at what VA calls adverse actions: reductions in monthly compensation or severance of service connection, which means VA no longer treats a condition as connected to military service[1]. The inspector general estimated that claims processors at the Veterans Benefits Administration (VBA) made one or more errors in about 9,300 of 27,100 such cases closed from Jan. 1 through Dec. 31, 2024[1]. The errors ran in both directions. Some veterans lost money before VA had given them the notice the law requires; others kept getting payments VA had already decided to stop[1].

The findings bear on a step that most veterans never see until a letter arrives. A reduction can follow medical improvement, a missed reexamination, or VA’s conclusion that an earlier rating rested on a clear and unmistakable error, known as a CUE[1].

What the law requires before VA cuts a rating

Under 38 C.F.R. § 3.103, which carries out 38 U.S.C. § 5104, VA cannot terminate, reduce or otherwise adversely affect compensation without first notifying the veteran[1]. The inspector general laid out the rights that follow from that rule: a written notice of the proposed action, 60 days to send evidence against it, a hearing on request, representation, and written notice of the final decision[1]. VBA’s procedures add five days for mail, so the proposal period runs 65 days[1].

Congress last overhauled the notice rules in the Veterans Appeals Improvement and Modernization Act of 2017, signed Aug. 23, 2017[2]. That law rewrote what every VA decision notice must contain, including identification of the issues decided, a summary of the evidence and the applicable law, findings favorable to the claimant, and “an explanation of how to obtain or access evidence used in making the decision”[2]. VA’s 2019 rule putting the law into effect revised § 3.103 and kept a separate guarantee for reductions: a veteran is “entitled to a hearing in connection with proposed adverse actions” before VA employees “who did not participate in the proposed action”[3].

The due process letter itself must state the proposed decision and new payment rates, the proposed effective date, any possible overpayment, the reasons, and the veteran’s rights to present evidence, ask for a hearing and have a representative[1]. If any of those is wrong, VBA’s rules treat the letter as insufficient and require a corrected one and a fresh due process period[1].

Where the errors were

The inspector general broke the estimated 9,300 flawed cases into four kinds of mistakes, and some cases had more than one[1]:

  • About 4,000 lacked sufficient due process before the adverse action was taken.
  • About 2,900 had rating codesheets, the summary of a veteran’s disability history, that were not updated.
  • About 2,900 used the wrong effective date for the reduction.
  • About 1,000 were proposed reductions with no final decision date.

About 4,000 of the flawed cases left veterans improperly paid, by the report’s estimate[1]. Where VA acted without sufficient due process, the inspector general wrote, the adverse action was, “in effect, premature”[1]. Fixing one means sending a new letter and waiting another 65 days before a final decision[1].

The report traced much of the problem to letters. None of the letter systems the reviewers examined had standard language for CUE reductions or for severance, and processors at the three regional offices visited (Columbia, South Carolina; Detroit; and St. Louis) used locally made templates[1]. VBA officials said they plan to move letters into the Veterans Benefits Management System (VBMS), its main claims system, and named CUE and severance letters as ones that need to be added; that work began in 2023 and has a tentative delivery window of late 2026 to early 2027, according to the report[1].

Most codesheet and effective-date errors also involved CUE cases[1]. Under VBA’s manual, a manager or designated reviewer must sign off on the proposed CUE decision, but the final decision needs no second signature unless new evidence has come in[1]. The inspector general found that in an estimated 4,400 of 5,900 flawed CUE cases, VA had received more evidence and still did not get that signature, and concluded that every final CUE decision should get another level of review[1].

Three cases from the report

The report described individual cases to show how the errors play out. In one, a processor proposed cutting a veteran’s heart condition rating from 100% to 10% because of a CUE, but the letter told the veteran the reason was improvement[1]. VA underpaid that veteran about $26,600 during 2024 and 2025, and the underpayment continues at about $2,200 a month until proper notice goes out, the inspector general said[1].

In another, VA sent a final notice on Nov. 5, 2024, and ended service connection effective March 1, 2025, when the correct date under its rules was Feb. 1[1]. The one-month delay meant an overpayment of about $300[1].

The third shows the closed-claim problem. VA proposed cutting a lung cancer rating from 100% to 30% for improvement, and the veteran did not respond[1]. A different processor then canceled the tracking record, called an end product, that kept the proposal open. The reduction never happened, and VA overpaid about $43,000 over 16 months, with about $2,700 a month still going out; the veteran had also been granted Dependents’ Educational Assistance in error[1]. VBA concurred with all three errors[1].

Is the problem still happening?

The 2024 sample cannot answer that fully, but the reviewers checked. In a judgmental sample of 20 cases from Jan. 1 through Sept. 30, 2025, nine of the 20 had no final rating decision, and end products had been closed early in both periods[1].

VBA knew about the pattern before the review began. In a March 2024 quality call, the Compensation Service told staff it had found “an alarming number of claims for proposed adverse action being closed after the 65-day due process period without a final rating decision,” according to the report[1]. Quality assurance staff told the inspector general that the Compensation Service did not follow up with regional offices afterward, and two of three local quality managers interviewed said their offices did not review the end products used for proposed reductions[1].

VBA also pointed to training. An official said the agency had released short “Minute Videos” in December 2025 on processing adverse actions[1]. The inspector general found the December videos did not cover the adverse actions in the report, and that a second set released in March 2026 did not address the deficiencies or the recommended fixes[1].

Concerns about the accuracy of faster claims decisions have come up in Congress this year, as earlier coverage of the claims backlog described. This review measures a narrower slice of the work: decisions that take benefits away.

What VA says it will do

J. Margarita Devlin, VBA’s principal deputy under secretary for benefits, concurred with the findings and all four recommendations in a July 15 memo[1]. VBA committed to standardized, required due process letters for CUE and severance cases by April 30, 2027; enhanced review of all final CUE reduction decisions by Sept. 30, 2026; and an automated report flagging proposed reductions with no final decision, also by Sept. 30[1]. On the fourth recommendation, correcting the errors found, VBA said 184 of 191 had been resolved as of June 22, with seven pending and a target of Oct. 31[1]. The inspector general said VBA’s plans were responsive and that it would close the recommendations once VBA shows evidence of progress[1].

The dollar totals are estimates. Because the sample produced highly variable point estimates, the inspector general reported lower bounds of a 90% confidence interval instead: at least $16.9 million in improper payments and at least $964,000 a month in ongoing ones[1].

If you’re affected

  • If you get a proposal letter: VA must give you 60 days to submit evidence before it reduces or ends your compensation, and VBA allows 65 days in practice[1]. Check that the letter states the reason, the proposed effective date and new payment rates, and your rights to evidence, a hearing and representation[1].
  • Hearings: You may ask for a hearing on a proposed adverse action, held by VA employees who did not take part in the proposal[3].
  • Representation: You have the right to be represented in the process[1]. VA’s notices must also tell you how to get the evidence used in a decision[2].
  • After a final decision: The decision notice must list the issues decided, the evidence and law considered, and how to seek further review[1, 2].
  • The report: The full review is posted at vaoig.gov under report No. 25-01011-154. The inspector general’s office lists (202) 461-4720 for questions about it[1].

Readers ask

How much notice does VA have to give before reducing my disability rating?
VA must first send a letter proposing the change and give you 60 days to submit evidence against it; VBA’s own procedures add five days for mail, for 65 days in all[1]. You can also ask for a hearing[1, 3].
What did the VA inspector general find about rating reductions?
It estimated that claims processors made at least one error in about 9,300 of 27,100 proposed reduction or severance cases closed in 2024, about 34%[1]. The errors produced at least $16.9 million in improper payments, counting both underpayments and overpayments[1].
Can VA reduce my rating if the due process letter gave the wrong reason?
Under VBA’s procedures, a letter that gets the reason, effective dates or rights wrong is insufficient, and staff must send a corrected letter and restart the due process period before taking final action[1].
When will VA fix the adverse action process?
VBA set Sept. 30, 2026, as its target for extra review of error-correction reductions and an automated report on unfinished cases, and April 30, 2027, for standardized letters[1]. It aimed to finish correcting the specific errors the inspector general found by Oct. 31, 2026[1].

Sources

  1. Review of VBA's Processing of Adverse Actions for Service-Connected Disability Compensation (Report No. 25-01011-154). VA Office of Inspector General, August 31, 2026.
  2. Veterans Appeals Improvement and Modernization Act of 2017 (Public Law 115-55). U.S. Government Publishing Office, August 23, 2017.
  3. VA Claims and Appeals Modernization (FR Doc. 2018-28350, 84 FR 138). Federal Register (Department of Veterans Affairs), January 18, 2019.

A note on sourcing

This report rests on the inspector general’s review and the law and regulation it applies. The error counts and dollar figures are statistical estimates from a sample of 229 cases; the inspector general reported the dollar amounts as conservative lower bounds because the point estimates were highly variable, and it did not separate underpayments from overpayments in its totals. The review covered cases closed in 2024 plus a small judgmental sample from 2025, so it does not show how often these errors occur today. VA’s management response, dated July 15, 2026, is the department’s only comment in the record; the piece does not include reaction from veterans service organizations or from members of the House or Senate Veterans’ Affairs Committees.

Filed underdisability compensation · VA claims · VA inspector general · due process · Veterans Benefits Administration

Return to THE FRONT PAGE