VA to strike Veterans Choice Program rules, seven years after community care replaced it
A final rule effective Aug. 27 deletes the 2014 program's regulations, which VA kept on the books to settle old claims. Community care eligibility, including a 40-mile carve-out for five states, does not change.
The Department of Veterans Affairs will delete the regulations for the Veterans Choice Program on Aug. 27, closing the books on the 2014 program that sent veterans facing long waits or long drives to private doctors[1, 3].
The final rule, published Tuesday in the Federal Register, does not change any veteran’s access to outside care. Since June 6, 2019, community care has run through the Veterans Community Care Program, which the 2018 MISSION Act created to replace Choice[1, 5, 7]. What the rule ends is a regulatory leftover. VA kept the Choice rules in force after 2019 so it could finish paying claims for care delivered under the old program, and it now says none remain[1].
What the July 28 rule removes
The rule strikes 38 CFR 17.1500 through 17.1540, along with the heading “Expanded Access to Non-VA Care Through the Veterans Choice Program” that sits above them[1]. It also scrubs references to Choice from three copayment sections: 17.108, for inpatient and outpatient care; 17.110, for medications; and 17.111, for extended care services[1]. In the medication section, a paragraph heading that read “Choice” will read “Community Care”[1].
The rewritten extended care sentence states plainly that for non-institutional care and extended care services furnished through the community care program, “the copayment amount at the time of furnishing such care or services by a non-VA entity or provider is $0”[1].
Secretary of Veterans Affairs Douglas A. Collins approved the rule on July 21[1]. VA skipped a public comment period, invoking the Administrative Procedure Act’s good-cause exception and calling comment “unnecessary” because the program’s authority had expired[1]. “VA cannot provide care pursuant to these regulations and they are therefore obsolete,” the rule says[1]. The White House regulatory office found the action not significant, and VA classified it as deregulatory under Executive Order 14192, with no new costs or reporting duties[1].
Why the Choice rules stayed on the books until 2026
When VA wrote the community care regulations in June 2019, it left the Choice sections in place[1, 7]. Some of them, including payment rates and limits on authorized care, were still needed to settle claims for care given before June 6, 2019, but processed after that date[1]. VA said in February 2019 that it would have to come back later to repeal them, according to the new rule[1].
The department now says that time has come. “At this time, VA believes that there is no possibility that any episode of care approved under the Veterans Choice Program regulations could still be active,” the rule states[1]. An episode of care under Choice could not run longer than a year, and the program ended more than seven years ago[1]. VA says no episodes of care or payments are pending[1].
How the Choice Program worked
Congress created Choice in the Veterans Access, Choice, and Accountability Act, signed Aug. 7, 2014[2]. The law put $10 billion into a Veterans Choice Fund, available only for the new program[2]. A veteran could use it after being unable to get an appointment within the Veterans Health Administration’s wait-time goals, or by living more than 40 miles from the nearest VA medical facility, including a community-based outpatient clinic[2]. Veterans in states without a full-service VA hospital who lived more than 20 miles from one in another state could also qualify, as could some who faced hard travel by air, boat or ferry[2, 3].
VA’s first rule, issued Nov. 5, 2014, set the wait-time goal at 30 days[3]. It limited the program to veterans enrolled in VA health care on or before Aug. 1, 2014, or within five years of separating after combat service[3]. An episode of care was capped at 60 days at the start, and veterans owed $0 at the appointment, with any VA copayment figured after the provider billed VA[3]. The program was authorized to run until Aug. 7, 2017, or until the fund ran out[3].
In April 2015 VA stopped measuring the 40 miles in a straight line and began using driving distance, saying the change would let more veterans take part and receive care closer to home[4].
What GAO found about Choice wait times
The program built to shorten waits had trouble meeting its own clock. In a June 4, 2018, report, the Government Accountability Office found that if VA medical centers and the two contractors that scheduled most Choice appointments used all the time VA allowed them, routine care could take up to 70 calendar days, against the law’s 30-day requirement[6].
In GAO’s sample of 55 routine authorizations from January through April 2016, the process took an average of at least 64 calendar days[6]. A VHA review of about 5,000 authorizations from July through September 2016 found an average of 51 days before veterans received care[6]. GAO also found later clinically indicated dates on about 23 percent of the 196 authorizations it examined, which could hide true waits, and found that about 28 percent of 53 urgent authorizations had been switched from routine to speed scheduling[6].
GAO blamed complex referral and scheduling steps, poor communication between VHA and its medical centers, and community provider networks that were too thin or poorly distributed[6]. It said the lessons could help VA as it folded Choice and its other outside-care programs into one[6].
What replaced it, and does the 40-mile rule still apply?
The MISSION Act, signed June 6, 2018, rewrote 38 U.S.C. 1703 to create the Veterans Community Care Program and ended VA’s authority to furnish care under Choice one year after enactment[5]. VA’s June 2019 rule lists six ways a veteran can qualify: VA does not offer the needed care; VA has no full-service medical facility in the veteran’s state; the veteran is grandfathered under Choice’s distance test; VA cannot meet its access standards; the veteran and referring clinician agree outside care is in the veteran’s best medical interest; or a VA service line falls short of quality standards[7].
The access standards replaced Choice’s 30-day goal and mileage test. For primary care, mental health care and non-institutional extended care, a veteran may elect community care if VA cannot schedule an appointment within 30 minutes’ average drive time and within 20 days of the request[7]. For specialty care, the limits are 60 minutes and 28 days[7]. VA said the drive-time standards tracked TRICARE Prime, which uses 30 minutes for primary care and 60 for specialty care for beneficiaries who are not on active duty[7]. Earlier this month VA also finalized a change to how veterans report community emergency care, as covered in earlier reporting on the 72-hour notice rule.
The 40-mile test survives in a narrow form. Under the 2019 rule, a veteran who was eligible under Choice’s distance provisions as of June 5, 2018, and still lives in a qualifying location keeps that eligibility with no end date if the veteran resides in Alaska, Montana, North Dakota, South Dakota or Wyoming[7]. Elsewhere, the carry-over applied only to veterans who had received VA care between June 6, 2017, and June 6, 2018, and who sought care before June 6, 2020[7]. Some commenters had urged VA to keep the 40-mile criterion for everyone; VA declined, saying the limited carry-over matched the MISSION Act[7].
That grandfather clause lives in 38 CFR 17.4010, the community care eligibility section, and it rests on the Choice Act itself rather than on the Choice regulations[7]. The July 28 rule does not amend 17.4010[1].
If you’re affected
Veterans do not need to do anything. The rescission takes effect Aug. 27, 2026, and changes no eligibility, access standard or copayment amount[1].
To ask for community care, a veteran contacts a VA official to request the needed care, and VA decides whether the veteran meets one of the eligibility conditions[7]. Veterans who move must tell VA within 60 days, and must give VA information on any other health plan that covers them before care is authorized[7].
Veterans in Alaska, Montana, North Dakota, South Dakota and Wyoming who qualified under Choice’s 40-mile test as of June 5, 2018, keep that route to community care while they live in a qualifying location[7].
For questions about the rule, VA lists Joseph Duran of the Veterans Health Administration at (303) 370-1637[1].
Readers ask
- Is the Veterans Choice Program still available?
- No. Its authority to furnish new care ended June 6, 2019, when the Veterans Community Care Program created by the MISSION Act took over[1, 5]. The July 28, 2026, rule removes the program’s leftover regulations as of Aug. 27[1].
- Does the Choice Program rescission change who qualifies for VA community care?
- No. The rule amends only the Choice sections and three copayment sections of VA’s medical regulations[1]. Community care eligibility is set by a separate section, 38 CFR 17.4010, which the rule leaves alone[1, 7].
- Can I still get VA community care because I live more than 40 miles from a VA facility?
- Only in limited cases. VA carried the old 40-mile test forward indefinitely for veterans who qualified under it as of June 5, 2018, still live in a qualifying spot and reside in Alaska, Montana, North Dakota, South Dakota or Wyoming[7]. Elsewhere, distance is now measured by VA’s average drive-time standards of 30 minutes for primary and mental health care and 60 minutes for specialty care[7].
- What are VA’s wait-time standards for community care?
- Twenty days from the date of request for primary care, mental health care and non-institutional extended care, and 28 days for specialty care, unless the veteran agrees to a later date with a VA provider[7]. If VA cannot meet the drive-time or wait-time standard, the veteran may elect community care[7].
- Do I owe a copay at the community provider’s office?
- For non-institutional and extended care furnished through the Veterans Community Care Program, the regulation as revised says the copayment owed when the care is given is $0[1]. VA’s copayment rules for community care otherwise stay in place[1, 7].
Sources
- Rescission of Outdated Veterans Choice Program Regulations (final rule, FR Doc. 2026-15210, RIN 2900-AS32). Department of Veterans Affairs, Federal Register, July 28, 2026.
- Public Law 113-146, Veterans Access, Choice, and Accountability Act of 2014. U.S. Government Publishing Office, August 7, 2014.
- Expanded Access to Non-VA Care Through the Veterans Choice Program (interim final rule, FR Doc. 2014-26316). Department of Veterans Affairs, Federal Register, November 5, 2014.
- Driving Distance Eligibility for the Veterans Choice Program (interim final rule, FR Doc. 2015-09370). Department of Veterans Affairs, Federal Register, April 24, 2015.
- Public Law 115-182, John S. McCain III, Daniel K. Akaka, and Samuel R. Johnson VA Maintaining Internal Systems and Strengthening Integrated Outside Networks Act of 2018. U.S. Government Publishing Office, June 6, 2018.
- Veterans Choice Program: Improvements Needed to Address Access-Related Challenges as VA Plans Consolidation of its Community Care Programs (GAO-18-281). U.S. Government Accountability Office, June 4, 2018.
- Veterans Community Care Program (final rule, FR Doc. 2019-11575). Department of Veterans Affairs, Federal Register, June 5, 2019.
A note on sourcing
This report rests on VA’s final rule as published in the Federal Register on July 28, 2026. VA’s statement that no Choice Program episodes of care or payments remain pending is the department’s own assessment; the rule does not give a count of claims closed since 2019. VA issued the rule without a public comment period, and the piece does not include comment from veterans service organizations. The Government Accountability Office’s wait-time figures come from 2016 samples that GAO described as not generalizable, and they describe the Choice Program, not current community care. Community care eligibility rules and access standards are described as VA adopted them in June 2019; the piece does not draw on later VA guidance on how those standards are applied.
Filed underVA health care · community care · Veterans Choice Program · MISSION Act · Federal Register
Return to THE FRONT PAGE