VA missed review of nearly 1 million unbilled visits that could have yielded up to $480 million, inspector general says
An audit of the fund that holds what VA collects from veterans' private insurers found half of all 'not billable' visits never reached the reports staff use to catch billing errors. VA plans a new report by December and may stop short of rebilling.
About 985,000 visits that the Department of Veterans Affairs marked “not billable” to private insurers never reached the reports its staff use to catch mistakes, the VA inspector general said in an Oct. 26 audit[1].
Those visits were valued at about $1.9 billion[1]. The inspector general estimates that reviewing them could bring in up to $480 million more from veterans’ private health insurers, money that by law flows back into VA medical care and is divided among the facilities that collect it[1, 5]. The audit covers January 2024 through August 2025, and VA’s own action plan sets November 2026 and January 2027 as target dates for fixes[1]. For veterans with private coverage, the money at stake is not a personal bill. It is a share of the budget that pays for their care, and, for some, a payment that can shrink a VA copay[2].
What the inspector general found
VA bills a veteran’s insurer when it treats a condition not related to military service and the veteran has coverage[1, 4]. When a visit cannot be billed, for example care for a service-connected condition, care under the PACT Act (the 2022 toxic exposure law) or a veteran with no insurance, staff assign one of 79 “reasons not billable” codes[1]. Some codes are generated by the system. Others are entered by hand[1].
VA policy requires facility revenue managers to pull a monthly report from VistA, the department’s older electronic health record, and check every inpatient stay and five specific codes to confirm that each was correctly marked[1]. Mistakes are sent to one of seven regional Consolidated Patient Account Centers for correction and billing[1].
Most codes were right. The inspector general estimated that staff correctly marked about 23 million of 23.2 million encounters in calendar 2024 as not billable, or about 99%[1]. The 1% that were wrong were not treated as a formal finding; the inspector general handed them to VA so it could collect[1].
The problem was what the reports left out. VA’s Corporate Data Warehouse, which draws mainly on VistA, held millions of coded visits that the VistA reports did not show[1]:
| Period | Encounters with a not-billable code | Not on VistA reports | Share missing |
|---|---|---|---|
| Calendar 2024 | about 23.5 million | about 12.6 million | 53.8% |
| January–August 2025 | about 15.2 million | about 8.6 million | 57% |
Source: VA OIG report 25-00148-252[1].
Of those missing visits, the ones that VA policy required staff to review numbered 254,377 in 2024, valued at about $763.8 million, and 730,898 in the first eight months of 2025, valued at about $1.2 billion[1]. The jump in 2025 came from sharp growth in two codes that require review, one of them added that year[1]. The audit does not name either code[1].
Revenue staff told auditors they had no access to the Corporate Data Warehouse, did not check whether the VistA reports were complete and did not know encounters were missing[1]. VHA policy does not require that check, the report says, though federal internal control standards call for managers to confirm that the information they rely on is complete[1].
How the inspector general arrived at $480 million
The estimate is a ceiling, and the report says so. The inspector general broke it into about $191 million for 2024 and $289 million for January through August 2025[1]. Each figure assumes the visit was for care unrelated to service, the service was eligible for insurance billing and the veteran had billable coverage[1].
The method came partly from VA. A VHA internal audit manager suggested multiplying average encounter costs by the missing encounters and then applying VA’s historical collection rates, which averaged 31.6% of billed inpatient care and 32.9% of billed outpatient care in fiscal 2024 and 2025[1]. VA had run its own numbers on a different dataset, and the two sets of results could not be compared[1].
What the inspector general could not get was an error rate. VHA’s internal audit manager said VA does not track how many not-billable encounters are later corrected to billable ones[1]. Without that, the inspector general said it could not claim a “reasonable monetary benefit” and did not count the $480 million as one, though it still believes VA can collect up to that amount[1].
The problem has a history. In 2012 the inspector general reported that VHA did not effectively identify VA-provided care that could have raised revenue by at least $152 million a year from 2010 through 2014[1].
VA’s plan and its 5% threshold
The acting under secretary for health, John Figueroa, agreed with all three recommendations in a Sept. 2 memo[1]. The VA Office of Information and Technology did not respond separately; its answer was folded into VHA’s[1].
VA’s action plan has three parts[1]:
- Find the cause. Revenue operations and the technology office will work out why VistA reports miss encounters and put in a fix. Target: November 2026.
- Build a new report. A new not-billable report using the Corporate Data Warehouse as its source is expected by December 2026, followed by updated procedures and controls. Target: January 2027.
- Sample before billing. Rather than reviewing every excluded encounter, VA will review a statistically valid sample in “mandatory and high-risk” categories to find the error rate. Target: January 2027.
The third step carries a condition. “If the error rate is ≤ 5%, no further action will be taken,” the plan says[1]. Above 5%, VA lists training, revised procedures and controls, and more oversight as the corrective steps[1]. The plan does not say whether VA will go back and bill insurers for specific past visits in either case[1].
The inspector general’s recommendation asked VA to review the excluded encounters and, where appropriate, bill insurers for as far back as the law allows[1]. It called VA’s planned actions “responsive” and said it will close the recommendations only when VA documents that they are in place[1]. Time is a factor: citing 38 U.S.C. § 1729, the inspector general says VA cannot recover from insurers after six years from the last day of care[1, 4]. By this report’s count, that window for the oldest visits in the audit, from January 2024, closes in early 2030[1, 4].
The report also flags an unknown. VA announced in December 2025 that it would reorganize VHA’s management over 18 to 24 months, and on May 1, 2026, the under secretary for health announced the consolidation of the regional networks from 18 to five[1]. The inspector general said that as of publication, the effect on the billing centers was unknown[1]. VA expects its newer Federal Electronic Health Record to be fully in place in 2031[1].
Why it matters to veterans with insurance
The Medical Care Collections Fund, created by the Balanced Budget Act of 1997, took in $3.8 billion in fiscal 2024 and $4.6 billion in fiscal 2025, and VA projected $4 billion for fiscal 2026 and $4.2 billion for 2027[1]. Federal law makes the money available for veterans’ medical care and for the cost of billing and collection[5]. Each VA facility gets back a share that matches its own collections[5]. A medical center that fails to bill a visit loses that money for its own budget.
Insurers cannot contract their way out. The statute says no state law and no contract provision can stop VA from collecting[4]. It also says the amount VA collects is reduced by any deductible or copayment the plan requires of the veteran, and that a veteran’s not having paid that deductible does not block collection[4].
If you’re affected
- No bill from the audit. The recommendations concern billing insurance companies[1]. VA says veterans do not have to pay any balance their insurer does not cover[2].
- Insurance can lower your copay. When a private insurer pays VA for non-service-connected care, VA says it may use the money to offset part or all of the veteran’s copay, and the insurer may count the charges toward the annual deductible[2].
- Who pays copays. Veterans with a service-connected rating of 10% or higher pay no outpatient or inpatient copay[3]. Others may owe $15 for a primary care visit and $50 for specialty care or tests such as an MRI for conditions not related to service[3].
- What VA does not bill. VA does not bill Medicare or Medicaid, though it may bill Medicare supplemental insurance[2].
- Your care is not at stake. Federal law bars VA from denying care, or requiring a copayment or deductible as a condition of care, because of its insurance-recovery authority[4]. VA says having or lacking insurance does not change the VA health benefits a veteran can get[2].
- Report questions about the audit to the inspector general’s office at 202-461-4720[1].
VA’s first deadline under the plan is this month: the finding on why VistA reports drop encounters, and a fix[1].
Readers ask
- Will VA send me a bill if it missed billing my insurance?
- No. VA bills the insurer, not the veteran, and VA says veterans do not owe any balance the insurer leaves unpaid[2]. The audit’s recommendations concern billing insurance companies[1].
- Why does VA ask for my private health insurance information?
- VA says it is required to bill private insurers for care of conditions not related to military service, and that insurer payments may offset part or all of a veteran’s VA copay[2]. VA does not bill Medicare or Medicaid but may bill Medicare supplemental plans[2].
- Can VA deny me care if I don’t have insurance or won’t pay a deductible?
- No. Federal law says a veteran cannot be denied care, or required to make a copayment or deductible payment to receive it, because of VA’s insurance-recovery authority[4].
Sources
- Audit of the Medical Care Collections Fund for VA-Provided Care (Report 25-00148-252). VA Office of Inspector General, October 26, 2026.
- VA health care and other insurance. U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs, accessed 2026-11-12.
- Current VA health care copay rates. U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs, accessed 2026-11-12.
- 38 U.S. Code § 1729 - Recovery by the United States of the cost of certain care and services. U.S. Congress, accessed 2026-11-12.
- 38 U.S. Code § 1729A - Department of Veterans Affairs Medical Care Collections Fund. U.S. Congress, accessed 2026-11-12.
A note on sourcing
The $480 million figure is the inspector general’s upper-bound estimate, built on a method VA’s revenue staff suggested and on VA’s historical collection rates; the inspector general did not claim it as a monetary benefit because VA does not track how many ‘not billable’ codes are later corrected. How much of it VA could still bill depends on care type, eligibility and each veteran’s coverage, none of which the audit resolved visit by visit. The report’s executive summary and its body give slightly different totals for 2025 encounters (about 15.3 million and about 15.2 million); this story uses the body and appendix figures. The early-2030 end of the six-year window for January 2024 visits is this report’s own count. VA’s target dates come from its September 2026 action plan printed in the report. The report does not say how the Veterans Health Administration’s reorganization will affect the regional billing centers, and this story does not draw on comment from insurers or veterans service organizations.
Filed underVA health care · VA OIG · private health insurance · Medical Care Collections Fund · copays · VistA
Return to THE FRONT PAGE