Skip to the stories

Edition of

Federal AffairsDispatch

Vol. I · No. 46Online edition

Veterans, service members and military families: the federal decisions that reach them.

Health CareCongress

Most VA facilities without locked psychiatric units lack required backup agreements for involuntary holds, inspector general finds

A national review released Nov. 12 found only 3 of 28 VA facilities without a locked mental health unit had the agreements VA policy requires for involuntary admissions elsewhere. VA concurred and set April 2027 to close the gap.

Most Department of Veterans Affairs medical facilities without a locked psychiatric unit lack the agreements VA requires to send veterans on involuntary mental health holds to outside hospitals, the VA inspector general reported Nov. 12[1].

Of 28 such facilities, three reported having the agreements[1]. The other 25 described informal steps they take to get patients evaluated and admitted in the community, which the inspector general said risks delays and poor coordination for veterans who urgently need hospitalization[1]. The review, which surveyed all 139 VA health care facilities between February 2025 and March 2026, also found 20 facilities with no written guidance on involuntary holds, tracking that was mostly manual or absent, and no systemwide training requirement[1]. The acting under secretary for health, John Figueroa, concurred with all seven recommendations in an Oct. 15 memo, and VA set April 2027 as its target to put the missing agreements in place[1].

An involuntary hold confines a person against their will, usually for a few days, so clinicians can decide whether the person meets a state’s standard for court-ordered treatment[1, 3]. The inspector general opened the national review after four earlier reports at individual facilities raised problems with how staff applied those state rules[1].

What the inspector general found at 139 facilities

The Veterans Health Administration (VHA), VA’s health care arm, runs locked mental health acute inpatient units at 111 facilities, or 80%[1]. At 101 of them, VA clinicians start the hold process themselves, and 97 also admit those patients to their own locked unit[1]. Four place patients on holds but do not admit them[1]. At 10 facilities, staff do not start holds at all because state statutes give that power to others, such as police, courts or county agencies; six of those 10 still admit a veteran after an outside official places the hold[1].

The 28 facilities without a locked unit are the ones that must send patients elsewhere. VA clinicians at 22 of them start holds, and staff at the remaining six do not[1]. VHA Directive 1160.01 requires every facility without a locked unit to have “agreements with appropriate agencies or hospitals” to arrange involuntary hospitalization when it is clinically necessary[1]. Three had them[1].

Written policy was uneven:

  • Guidance. 119 facilities (86%) said they had a local policy on managing patients who need involuntary holds, and 113 of those said it matched state law[1]. Twenty facilities said they had none[1].
  • Legal review. VHA policy recommends, but does not require, that facilities consult VA’s district counsel when writing local rules[1]. Forty-three of 126 respondents, about 34%, said they had[1].
  • Quality. About 20% of the documents facilities submitted were incomplete, unsigned or both, and VHA sets no required elements for them[1].
  • Coordinators. A July 30, 2025, VHA memo told every facility to name a point of contact on involuntary commitment, and an alternate, by Aug. 11, 2025[1]. When the inspector general checked on April 14, 2026, 79 facilities (57%) had both, and 15 (11%) had neither[1].

Why state law, not VA, sets the rules

VA’s inpatient mental health directive states the legal premise plainly: “the Federal government does not have civil commitment laws”[1]. Each state sets its own criteria and procedures, and VHA leaves it to each medical center director to align facility guidelines with them[1, 3].

The differences are large. A hold before further review can last 23 hours in North Dakota and 10 days in New Hampshire and Rhode Island; 72 hours is the most common period[1, 3]. In New York, people medically certified for admission may be held up to 60 days without a court order, and three states (Kansas, Nebraska and West Virginia) set no period at all, according to the Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration (SAMHSA)[3]. SAMHSA’s guide describes civil commitment as an order by a judge, or someone acting as one, confining a person with a serious mental disorder to a psychiatric hospital or supervised outpatient treatment[3].

Getting the state rules wrong has consequences. In an August 2024 report from Gainesville, Florida, the inspector general substantiated that staff admitted a patient as involuntary even though the patient asked to be admitted voluntarily, and that staff misapplied the examination criteria in Florida’s Baker Act[2]. The patient later disengaged from VA mental health care and died by suicide; the inspector general said it could not determine whether different care would have changed the outcome[2]. All of that report’s recommendations were closed as of Oct. 19, 2026[1]. A December 2025 inspection in Martinsburg, West Virginia, still had two open recommendations on aligning its hold process with state law as of the same date[1].

VA could not count veterans on involuntary holds

VHA’s national director of inpatient mental health services told the inspector general that VHA had no enterprise-wide way to identify patients on an involuntary hold[1]. Only 48 of 133 facilities asked (36%) tracked hold data, often with staff entering data by hand into spreadsheets or logs[1]. Among the 97 facilities that both start holds and admit patients to a locked unit, 18 tracked how many patients converted to voluntary status during their stay[1].

The Senate Veterans’ Affairs Committee had flagged inconsistent data and asked VHA’s Office of Mental Health to improve its national count, according to the report[1]. VHA’s answer is a legal status field in the electronic health record that requires an order each time a patient’s status changes on a locked unit[1]. The programming went to facilities on June 2, 2026; by Aug. 14, six were still working on it[1]. VA told the inspector general that every admitting inpatient mental health unit had the order in place as of Oct. 5, and that a dashboard launched Oct. 1 shows whether each admitted patient has a valid status recorded and whether an involuntary status changed to voluntary[1]. The inspector general closed those recommendations[1].

Training is the least settled area. VHA requires inpatient mental health staff to be trained in relevant regulations but does not require training specific to involuntary holds, and does not require any hold training for staff outside inpatient units, such as emergency departments or outpatient clinics[1]. About three-quarters of facilities said their training covers local policy (99) or state law (103), and 63 said it covers city or county law[1].

When VA plans to act

VA’s action plan, signed by Figueroa, sets these targets[1]:

Recommendation VA’s plan Target
Agreements at facilities without locked units Memo requiring agreements; regional mental health leads attest April 2027
Hold procedures in facility guidelines Memo stressing guidelines must cover holds, admissions and hospitalization April 2027
Require district counsel review Consult general counsel and weigh feasibility of revising the directive December 2026
Hold-specific training Consider feasibility of assessing local training needs November 2026
Points of contact, legal status field, reports Completed; recommendations closed Closed

The plan arrives during a reorganization. VA consolidated its regional networks from 18 to five, effective June 1, 2026, and the inspector general said recommendations aimed at former network directors now apply to their successors[1].

If you’re affected

  • In crisis now. The Veterans Crisis Line is free, confidential and open 24 hours a day: dial 988, then Press 1, or text 838255[6]. Veterans do not need to be enrolled in VA benefits or health care to use it[6]. Callers with hearing loss can use TTY at 1-800-799-4889[6].
  • Which rules apply. The hold process follows the law of the state where the veteran is when it happens, not a single VA standard[1, 3]. During a hold, a person may be offered treatment and, typically, the chance to accept a voluntary admission instead[3].
  • Rights if a hold leads to a hearing. SAMHSA’s review of state laws says people facing commitment have rights to notice of hearings, help from a lawyer, and to testify, present evidence and question witnesses, and that every state requires at least clear and convincing evidence to commit someone[3].
  • Firearms. Federal law makes it unlawful for a person who “has been committed to a mental institution” to possess a firearm[4]. The federal definition covers a formal commitment by a court, board, commission or other lawful authority and does not include a person in an institution “for observation” or a voluntary admission[5]. The inspector general’s review did not examine this question[1].
  • Questions about the report go to the inspector general’s office at 202-461-4720[1].

VA’s first answer on training is due this month, and its plan commits only to considering whether an assessment of local training needs is feasible, given that state laws vary and procedures may differ even within a state[1].

Readers ask

Can a VA doctor put a veteran on an involuntary psychiatric hold?
In many places, yes. VA clinicians at 101 of the 111 facilities with locked units and at 22 of the 28 without one start involuntary holds, but whether they may do so depends on state law[1]. At 10 facilities, state statutes give that authority to others, such as law enforcement, courts or county agencies[1].
How long can an involuntary mental health hold last?
It depends on the state where the veteran is. Holds range from 23 hours in North Dakota to 10 days in New Hampshire and Rhode Island, and 72 hours is the most common period[1, 3].
What happens if my VA medical center has no locked psychiatric unit?
VA policy requires those facilities to have agreements with outside agencies or hospitals for involuntary admissions[1]. Only 3 of 28 such facilities reported having them; VA says it will require the agreements and set April 2027 as its target[1].
Does an emergency psychiatric hold affect gun ownership under federal law?
Federal law bars possession of firearms by anyone ‘committed to a mental institution’[4]. The federal definition covers formal commitments by a court, board or other lawful authority and excludes a person held ‘for observation’ or admitted voluntarily[5]. The inspector general’s review did not address firearms[1].
Where can a veteran in crisis get help right away?
The Veterans Crisis Line answers 24 hours a day at 988, then Press 1, or by text to 838255, and callers do not need to be enrolled in VA benefits or health care[6].

Sources

  1. Overview of Involuntary Mental Health Holds at VHA Facilities (Report 25-00867-171). VA Office of Inspector General, November 12, 2026.
  2. Incorrect Use of the Baker Act at the North Florida/South Georgia Veterans Health System in Gainesville, Florida (Report 23-03677-237). VA Office of Inspector General, August 28, 2024.
  3. Civil Commitment and the Mental Health Care Continuum: Historical Trends and Principles for Law and Practice. Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration, accessed 2026-11-13.
  4. 18 U.S. Code § 922 - Unlawful acts. U.S. Congress, accessed 2026-11-13.
  5. 27 CFR § 478.11 - Meaning of terms. Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives, accessed 2026-11-13.
  6. Veterans Crisis Line. U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs, accessed 2026-11-13.

A note on sourcing

The inspector general’s figures come from questionnaires VA facilities filled out in 2025 and describe conditions as each facility reported them at the time; the inspector general notes that answers were self-reported and that not every respondent answered follow-up questions. The review examined policies, staffing designations, data and training, not individual patient outcomes, and it did not test whether facility policies actually comply with state law. VA told the inspector general that all facilities had named a commitment point of contact by Sept. 5, 2025, while the inspector general’s own check found 57% had both a contact and an alternate as of April 14, 2026; the report closes that recommendation without reconciling the two. VA’s target dates are month-only and come from its October 2026 action plan printed in the report. The federal firearms provisions cited here are included for context; the review did not address firearms, and how they apply to any individual hold depends on the facts and state process involved. This story does not draw on comment from veterans service organizations or the Senate Veterans’ Affairs Committee.

Filed underVA health care · mental health · VA OIG · involuntary holds · civil commitment · Veterans Crisis Line

Return to THE FRONT PAGE