Skip to the stories

Edition of

Federal AffairsDispatch

Vol. I · No. 46Online edition

Veterans, service members and military families: the federal decisions that reach them.

BenefitsCongress

VA caregiver program appeals took 416 days on average, inspector general finds

Higher-level reviews and supplemental claims in VA's family caregiver stipend program ran more than 10 times longer than clinical appeals, and a VA form tells families a supplemental claim can be filed 'at any time.' VA says it will start posting wait times this month.

Families who asked the Department of Veterans Affairs to reconsider a family caregiver program decision through a formal decision review waited about 416 days on average, VA’s inspector general reported Oct. 28[1].

The finding reaches the households in VA’s most generous caregiver benefit, the Program of Comprehensive Assistance for Family Caregivers (PCAFC), which pays a monthly stipend to a veteran’s primary family caregiver and can add health coverage through CHAMPVA, at least 30 days of respite care a year and legal and financial planning help[3]. The program serves veterans with a VA disability rating of 70% or higher who need at least six months of continuous, in-person personal care[3]. A denial, a discharge or a lower stipend tier can be contested several ways, and the audit found the routes differ by more than a year in how long they take[1]. VA has also promised to begin publishing those wait times this month[1].

Two ways to contest a caregiver decision, and two very different clocks

Under the Appeals Modernization Act of 2017, a family can ask for a higher-level review, in which a Caregiver Support Program reviewer reexamines the evidence behind the decision, or file a supplemental claim with new and relevant evidence[1]. A third route sends the case to the Board of Veterans’ Appeals, which the audit did not examine[1]. Separately, the Veterans Health Administration (VHA) offers a clinical appeal, a request that a different centralized eligibility and appeal team review the medical determination behind the decision[1].

The Office of Inspector General (OIG) measured each route from the day a request was filed to the day it was decided[1].

Route Period Completed or filed Average days Share granted
Higher-level review Feb. 2022 to March 2025 2,595 filed about 444 about 3%
Supplemental claim Feb. 2022 to March 2025 4,796 filed about 404 about 4%
Clinical appeal Oct. 2020 to March 2025 17,346 filed about 36 about 12% (level 1), 10% (level 2)
Decision reviews April to Dec. 2025 3,284 completed about 581 about 4% each
Clinical appeals April to Dec. 2025 1,861 completed 37 about 11% (level 1), 6% (level 2)

Source: VA OIG report 25-01406-224[1].

Decision reviews completed in the last nine months of 2025 ranged from one day to 1,348 days[1]. The fiscal-year breakdown shows modest progress on the oldest filings: the share of decision reviews completed within 365 days rose from about 15% of those filed in fiscal 2022 to about 31% of those filed in fiscal 2024[1]. As of April 1, 2025, 3,677 decision reviews filed since fiscal 2021 were still open[1].

Clinical appeals have a written timeliness goal. VHA Directive 1041 calls for a level 1 decision within 45 business days, and a level 2 appeal that needs outside review must be finished no more than 60 days after VHA receives it[1]. Decision reviews had no such goal, the OIG found, and the program’s own performance standards for staff covered intake speed and quarterly output rather than total wait[1]. “Without clinical appeals, veterans and caregivers would have to wait, on average, more than 10 times longer to have their claims decided,” the report said[1].

Program leaders told auditors the OIG’s method was sound but that they measure timeliness differently, projecting a typical wait from six months of workload averages[1]. The OIG said that approach may help estimate current processing but “is not effective at determining how long veterans waited for a decision”[1].

How did caregiver decisions get into the appeals system?

The caregiver statute says a decision “affecting the furnishing of assistance or support shall be considered a medical determination”[6]. Until 2021, a clinical appeal was the only way to contest a program decision[1]. In April 2021, the Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims ruled in Beaudette v. McDonough that caregiver program benefits decisions can be appealed to the Board, and VA began offering all three Appeals Modernization Act routes[1]. The Federal Circuit affirmed on Feb. 27, 2024, holding that the statute’s bar reaches only decisions on furnishing assistance or support, not every program decision[7].

The program started issuing decision reviews on Feb. 11, 2022[1]. The program’s legacy participants and legacy applicants are in a transition period that a September 2025 VA rule extended through Sept. 30, 2028[4]. Congress has also tightened notice rules: as amended by Public Law 118-210, the statute requires decision letters to include all criteria used to determine eligibility and, after an evaluation, how those criteria were applied[6].

A related reporting gap dates to 2023. The Appeals Modernization Act requires VA to publish average processing times for higher-level reviews and supplemental claims, but its text refers to the Veterans Benefits Administration’s regional offices[1]. VHA asked VA’s Office of General Counsel in September 2023 whether the requirement covers health programs and had no answer as of May 2026, the OIG said[1]. A September 2023 OIG recommendation on the same question remained open in July 2026[1]. The program shares some counts with veterans service organizations but not processing times[1].

A backlog and a form the OIG says is misleading

Auditors found 703 decision reviews waiting in VA’s Centralized Mail Portal in July 2026, some submitted as far back as October 2025, down about 56% from December 2025[1]. Program officials blamed part of the delay on forms that are filled out incorrectly or sent to the wrong address, which can route them to the benefits administration or the Board first, though the portal could not export data to measure that[1]. For supplemental claims, the program’s director of review and appeals said gathering new evidence can take about 300 days in many cases[1].

The OIG’s third finding concerns VA Form 10-305, the notice of review rights VA includes with every caregiver decision[1, 2]. The form says, “A Supplemental Claim may be filed at any time”[1]. That is true as far as it goes, but under 38 U.S.C. 5110, a supplemental claim filed within one year of the decision keeps the original application date as the effective date, while a later filing is dated from the day it arrives[1, 5]. The OIG said families “could be missing out on earlier effective dates, resulting in fewer benefits received”[1]. VHA’s interim staff guidance, Notice 2025-09, has the same gap, the report said[1].

What VA says it will change

Acting Under Secretary for Health John Figueroa concurred with all three recommendations in an Aug. 27 response[1]. VHA said the Caregiver Support Program intends to decide higher-level reviews and supplemental claims within 60 days of receiving a complete request, a request that includes everything needed to start the review, and added a field to its workflow system in June 2026 to track when a request becomes complete[1]. The target date for that goal and an updated instruction manual is December 2026[1].

VHA said staff were realigned in July 2025, missing information has been collected by phone since March 2026, and the backlog has fallen by more than 70%, so that by the end of fiscal 2026 the program would be processing completed claims within 60 days[1]. It said it will publish on caregiver.va.gov the number of reviews in the queue and timeliness metrics, with a November 2026 target, and will revise Form 10-305 and replace Notice 2025-09 with a directive by January 2027[1]. The Veterans Benefits Administration concurred without comment[1].

The program’s appeals page, updated Nov. 6, still told callers that staff “won’t be able to give you an exact timeline” for a decision[2].

For more on how higher-level reviews work in VA’s disability claims system, see this site’s earlier coverage.

If you’re affected

  • Watch the one-year mark. To preserve the earliest effective date, file a supplemental claim or higher-level review within one year of the date on the decision notice[1, 5].
  • Consider a clinical appeal alongside a review. The program allows a clinical appeal at the same time as a higher-level review or supplemental claim, and clinical appeals averaged about 36 days in the audit period[1]. Only one Appeals Modernization Act option may be pursued at a time[1].
  • Use the right forms and address. Supplemental claims go on VA Form 20-0995 and higher-level reviews on VA Form 20-0996, mailed to Caregiver Support Program, Veterans Affairs Evidence Intake Center, PO Box 5154, Janesville, WI 53547[2]. VA says fax, QuickSubmit or another address will cause a failed submission[2]. Board appeals use VA Form 10182[2].
  • Check status by phone. The Caregiver Support Line, 1-855-260-3274, can tell the filer which of four stages a request is in[2].
  • Get help if you want it. VA says an accredited representative, attorney or claims agent can assist with a review or appeal[2].

Readers ask

How long does a VA caregiver program higher-level review take?
The inspector general found higher-level reviews of caregiver program decisions averaged about 444 days from filing to decision between February 2022 and March 2025[1]. VA says it now aims to decide complete requests within 60 days[1].
Is there a deadline to file a supplemental claim for a PCAFC decision?
To keep the earliest possible effective date, file within one year of the decision notice, the inspector general said, citing 38 U.S.C. 5110[1, 5]. A claim filed later is dated from the day it is filed, which can reduce back pay[1].
Can I file a clinical appeal and a supplemental claim at the same time for the caregiver program?
Yes. The Caregiver Support Program allows a clinical appeal to run alongside a higher-level review or supplemental claim[1]. Clinical appeals averaged about 36 days in the audit period[1].
Where do I mail a caregiver program higher-level review or supplemental claim?
VA says to mail VA Form 20-0996 or 20-0995 to Caregiver Support Program, Veterans Affairs Evidence Intake Center, PO Box 5154, Janesville, WI 53547[2]. VA warns that fax, QuickSubmit or any other address will result in a failed submission[2].
How do I check the status of a caregiver program decision review?
Call the Caregiver Support Line at 1-855-260-3274[2]. VA says staff can tell the person who filed which stage the request is in, but not give an exact timeline[2].

Sources

  1. Audit of Caregiver Support Program Appeals Processes (Report 25-01406-224). VA Office of Inspector General, October 28, 2026.
  2. Caregiver Support Program (CSP) Review and Appeals. U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs, accessed 2026-11-08.
  3. The Program of Comprehensive Assistance for Family Caregivers. U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs, accessed 2026-11-08.
  4. Extension of Program of Comprehensive Assistance for Family Caregivers Eligibility for Legacy Participants and Legacy Applicants (FR Doc. 2025-18827, 90 FR 46477). U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs, September 29, 2025.
  5. 38 U.S. Code § 5110 - Effective dates of awards. Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School, accessed 2026-11-08.
  6. 38 U.S. Code § 1720G - Assistance and support services for caregivers. Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School, accessed 2026-11-08.
  7. Beaudette v. McDonough, No. 2022-1264. U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit, February 27, 2024.

A note on sourcing

The wait-time figures are the inspector general’s, measured from the date a request was filed to the date of decision. VA’s Caregiver Support Program told auditors it measures timeliness differently, with six-month workload projections, and the report notes its data could not show delays caused by incomplete submissions. VA’s statements that the backlog has fallen by more than 70% and that completed requests will be decided within 60 days come from VA’s written response to the draft report and have not been checked by the inspector general. VA’s target dates are given only by month. As of the Caregiver Support Program’s appeals page updated Nov. 6, VA had not posted the promised wait-time metrics. The piece does not address appeals to the Board of Veterans’ Appeals, which the audit excluded.

Filed undercaregivers · PCAFC · VA OIG · decision reviews · Appeals Modernization Act · Caregiver Support Program

Return to THE FRONT PAGE