VA inspector general estimates 38% of painful scar rating decisions had errors
An audit of decisions under diagnostic code 7804 found ratings granted without exam proof of tenderness and painful scars split across duplicate codes. VA disputes the projections, plans to correct the cases by Feb. 28 and expects a revised scars exam form Jan. 10.
The Department of Veterans Affairs’ inspector general estimates that about 38% of decisions granting or raising ratings for painful scars over a recent 12-month span contained errors, and that at least $5.6 million in overpayments resulted[1].
The audit reaches a large group. About 538,000 veterans were receiving VA benefits for service-connected painful scars as of July 24, 2026, according to Veterans Benefits Administration (VBA) data cited in the report[1]. The scars can come from burns, surgeries, shrapnel and gunshot wounds, Stars and Stripes reported[2]. The fixes VA has promised land in the next four months: a revised exam questionnaire tentatively due Jan. 10, a quality assurance briefing for raters by Jan. 31 and corrections to the flagged cases by Feb. 28[1]. A separate VA proposal to write the evidence requirement into the rating schedule has been pending since September 2025[3].
How VA rates a painful scar
Painful scars are rated under diagnostic code 7804 of the skin section of VA’s Schedule for Rating Disabilities, 38 CFR 4.118[4]. The percentage turns on the count, not the severity: one or two unstable or painful scars rate 10%, three or four rate 20%, and five or more rate 30%[4]. If one or more scars are both unstable and painful, 10% is added to the total[4]. Scars rated under other skin codes, such as 7805 for scars that limit function, may also receive a 7804 rating when they become painful[4].
Two other rules matter here. VA’s Adjudication Procedures Manual says a compensable painful scar rating needs objective evidence, meaning the examiner documents during the physical exam whether the scar is tender to touch; the veteran’s account of pain alone does not qualify[1]. And 38 CFR 4.14 bars “pyramiding,” rating the same disability under several diagnoses[5].
What did the inspector general find in painful scar decisions?
The Office of Inspector General (OIG) drew a stratified random sample of 130 decisions completed from June 1, 2024, through May 31, 2025: 70 grants of service connection, out of 43,762, and 60 increased ratings, out of 4,195[1]. Auditors also visited the Houston regional office in December 2025, held a virtual visit with the New Orleans office in January 2026 and interviewed 20 claims processors[1].
The OIG projected that about 15,400 grants (36%) and about 2,400 increases (58%) had at least one error, or about 17,900 decisions in all[1]. It found no underpayments[1]. Its estimated counts by error type:
| Error | Estimated decisions |
|---|---|
| No objective evidence that the scar was painful | 7,400 |
| More than one diagnostic code 7804 used for painful scars | 5,500 |
| No separate 7804 rating when an already rated scar became painful | 1,300 |
Source: VA OIG report 25-03303-266[1]. Some decisions had more than one type of error[1].
The report’s examples show how each error happens. In one, a veteran’s keloid scar on the ear was rated 10% after the exam form recorded aching pain in the medical history section, but the physical exam did not show the scar was tender to touch; the ongoing overpayment had reached about $6,900 by March 2026[1]. In another, a veteran with tender scars on the right hand and left flank received two 10% ratings, each under 7804, instead of a single 10% rating for both; that overpayment had reached about $5,200[1]. In a third, a back scar rated 0% under 7805 became painful, and the rater replaced the 7805 rating with a 10% rating under 7804 instead of keeping both[1]. That error cost the veteran nothing at the time, the OIG said, but losing the 7805 rating could affect future evaluations[1].
The OIG estimated that a minimum of about 920 erroneous decisions produced at least about $5.6 million in overpayments, which it said “will continue to accrue until VBA takes corrective action”[1]. After briefing VBA in February 2026, auditors checked 30 decisions from January 2026 and found a 43% error rate[1].
Claims processors told auditors the scars disability benefits questionnaire (DBQ), the standard exam form, was confusing: five of the 20 said they had trouble with it, and 13 said a revision could help[1]. When auditors showed processors a sample codesheet with two 7804 entries, six of 20 did not spot the error[1]. VBA’s rating software flagged pyramiding for other conditions but not for 7804 until April 19, 2026, when VBA added a warning in response to the review[1].
VA’s objection to the numbers
VA concurred with all three recommendations but challenged how the findings are presented[1]. In its written response, VBA said the OIG examined about 0.27% of the review population and found 60 errors, and that “only seven of the 60 errors OIG found resulted in improper payments”[1]. The remaining 53, it said, were technical or procedural issues[1].
VA press secretary Quinn Slaven put it more sharply to Stars and Stripes. “As part of this report, the IG examined 130 cases, found only seven instances of benefit overpayments to veterans, and then used that small sample size to draw conclusions about thousands of other unrelated benefits decisions it did not review,” Slaven said[2]. Slaven also said VA “will in the coming months re-examine any incorrect decisions the OIG identified to ensure they are correct and comply with all VA policies”[2].
The OIG made no material changes in response[1]. It said its figures describe errors in the population during the review period and are “not future-error forecasting,” and that the share of a population sampled has little effect on precision, which depends mostly on absolute sample size[1]. Because only seven sampled errors affected payment, the dollar projection varied widely, so the OIG reported the one-sided lower bound, about $5.6 million[1].
A pending rule on objective evidence
The objective-evidence requirement auditors cited lives in VA’s manual, not in the text of 4.118 itself[1, 4]. VA proposed on Sept. 29, 2025, to add a Note (4) to code 7804 stating that “Pain must be confirmed by objective evidence upon evaluation or demonstration”[3]. VA said the requirement dates to the 1945 rating schedule, when the code was titled “Scars, superficial, tender and painful on objective demonstration,” and that removing the words “on examination” from the title in 2008 was not meant to drop it[3]. VA said the changes “will not impact benefit payments” and found no transfers or costs associated with the rule[3]. Comments closed Nov. 28, 2025[3]. As of this month, the eCFR text of 4.118 still lists three notes under 7804[4].
This site has reported on earlier inspector general findings about errors in VA rating reductions, the process that applies when VA proposes to cut a rating.
If you’re affected
- Know what the exam should record. Under VA guidance, a compensable painful scar rating requires the examiner to document whether the scar is tender to touch on physical exam[1]. VBA revised the scars DBQ to ask for this more clearly; its tentative release date is Jan. 10, 2027[1].
- Check how multiple scars are coded. All painful scars should appear under a single 7804 entry, rated by the number of scars[4, 5]. A scar already rated under another skin code can also carry a separate 7804 rating if it becomes painful[4].
- Know the reduction process. When VA considers a lower rating that would reduce current payments, it must send a proposal with its reasons and allow 60 days to submit evidence before final action[6]. VA’s rules provide that an award reduced because of administrative error or error in judgment alone is reduced as of the date of last payment[6, 7]. The OIG report does not say how VBA will handle the cases it is correcting[1].
- Questions about the report can go to the OIG at (202) 461-4720[1].
VBA’s target for finishing corrections to the flagged decisions is Feb. 28, 2027[1]. The OIG closed the questionnaire recommendation on VBA’s documentation and will keep the other two open until VBA shows they are done[1].
Readers ask
- Will VA lower my painful scar rating because of the inspector general report?
- The report covers the decisions auditors flagged: VBA agreed to review and correct the errors the inspector general identified, with a target date of Feb. 28, 2027[1]. Under VA rules, a proposed reduction that would cut current payments comes with written reasons and 60 days to submit evidence[6].
- What counts as objective evidence of a painful scar for a VA rating?
- VA guidance says the examiner must document whether the scar is tender to touch during the physical exam; a veteran’s reported history of pain alone is not enough for a compensable rating under diagnostic code 7804[1]. A pending VA proposal would write that requirement into the rating schedule as a new note[3].
- Can I get a separate 10% rating for each painful scar?
- No. Painful scars are rated together under one diagnostic code 7804 by how many there are: 10% for one or two, 20% for three or four and 30% for five or more[4]. Two separate 7804 ratings for two scars is the pyramiding error the inspector general found[1, 5].
- When will VA release the new scars disability benefits questionnaire?
- VBA’s tentative release date for the revised Scars/Disfigurement DBQ is Jan. 10, 2027, and VBA says that date could change[1].
Sources
- Review of Accuracy of Claims Processors' Disability Evaluation Decisions for Painful Scars (Report 25-03303-266). VA Office of Inspector General, October 21, 2026.
- Federal watchdog identifies errors on veteran disability decisions for 'painful scars'. Stars and Stripes, October 21, 2026.
- Objective Evidence of Pain for Painful Scars Under DC 7804 (FR Doc. 2025-18829, 90 FR 46542, RIN 2900-AS37). U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs, September 29, 2025.
- 38 CFR 4.118 - Schedule of ratings - skin. U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs, accessed 2026-11-09.
- 38 CFR 4.14 - Avoidance of pyramiding. U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs, accessed 2026-11-09.
- 38 CFR 3.105 - Revision of decisions. U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs, accessed 2026-11-09.
- 38 CFR 3.500 - General (effective dates of reduction or discontinuance). U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs, accessed 2026-11-09.
A note on sourcing
The 17,900 error figure and the 38% rate are the inspector general’s projections from a stratified sample of 130 decisions, in which auditors found 60 errors, seven of them affecting payment. The $5.6 million overpayment figure is the lower bound of a 90% confidence interval, not a point estimate. VA disputes how the projections are presented, and its objection is reported here at similar weight. VBA’s Jan. 10, 2027 release date for the revised scars questionnaire is described by VBA as tentative and subject to change. The report does not say how VBA will correct individual decisions or whether any affected veteran will be asked to repay money; the regulatory provisions described in this story are general rules, not a statement of what VBA will do in these cases. VA’s proposed rule on objective evidence of pain had not been finalized in the Federal Register as of publication. This story does not draw on comment from veterans service organizations, which the inspector general interviewed but did not quote.
Filed underdisability compensation · VA OIG · rating schedule · painful scars · DBQ · claims accuracy
Return to THE FRONT PAGE