Skip to the stories

Edition of

Federal AffairsDispatch

Vol. I · No. 46Online edition

Veterans, service members and military families: the federal decisions that reach them.

Health CareCongress

VA paid $11.2 million for Veterans Crisis Line backup service it did not receive, inspector general finds

The inspector general found a contracted backup center took almost no calls for nearly a year while VA kept paying. VA agreed to weigh recovering the money but called the security lapse an isolated error.

From mid-July 2022 through June 2023, the contractor hired to back up the Veterans Crisis Line sent just two calls to its backup center, while the Department of Veterans Affairs paid about $11.2 million for the service, VA’s inspector general reported Sept. 1[1].

The review, report No. 23-03464-146, found that VA kept approving monthly invoices for nearly a year after its own staff knew the backup call center could not legally operate and did not have enough people to answer calls[1]. “VA’s oversight of this contract fell short,” the inspector general concluded[1]. VA agreed to ask its lawyers whether to try to recover the money, but it disputed that the mistake behind the delay points to a wider problem[1].

The crisis line is VA’s round-the-clock, confidential suicide prevention service, open to all veterans whether or not they use VA benefits or health care[1]. The report cites VA data putting the veteran suicide rate at about 35 deaths per 100,000, almost twice the rate among other U.S. adults[1].

What the backup center was supposed to do

Congress has required backup coverage to work for nearly a decade. The No Veterans Crisis Line Call Should Go Unanswered Act, signed Nov. 28, 2016, directed VA to set measurable performance goals for the line, “including at backup call centers,” and to plan for each call, text and other message to be “answered in a timely manner by a person”[2]. The law also called for periodic testing of the line and its backup centers each fiscal year[2].

In April 2019, VA awarded a $32.5 million firm-fixed-price contract, for one base year and four option years, to route calls to the crisis line, run its online chat infrastructure and provide backup call responders[1]. The backup portion was worth about $20.5 million, or 63% of the contract, and the contractor handed that work to a subcontractor[1]. The contract required backup responders to answer 10% of calls that came in through the contractor, which the contract called “purposeful calls” meant to keep the responders in practice, and to take every call if the crisis line itself went down[1].

The stakes rose in 2022. The National Suicide Hotline Designation Act of 2020, signed Oct. 17, 2020, made 988 the national number for the suicide prevention lifeline and for the Veterans Crisis Line[3]. The crisis line adopted “988 press 1” in July 2022[1].

How the backup center went dark

In April 2022, the contractor told VA that its original subcontractor would stop providing backup service; that subcontract ended July 15, 2022[1]. A new subcontractor was set to start the same day, the day before 988 press 1 took effect[1]. Within about a week of the contractor’s April notice, crisis line leaders began building an internal backup system with VA’s Office of Information and Technology, and it was minimally operational by May 2022[1].

The new subcontractor could not take calls. It planned to use a cloud-based system, and VA officials then concluded that it needed an authority to operate, the federal approval that allows a system handling sensitive data to be used, along with FedRAMP certification for cloud services[1]. In an October 2022 draft issue brief, a crisis line technology official estimated compliance would take 12 to 18 months[1].

That requirement should not have been a surprise, according to the report. When VA awarded the contract in 2019, the contracting officer, the contracting officer’s representative and an information security officer decided that no authority to operate was needed, even though the work statement required the contractor to transmit call documentation within 30 minutes and the contract said “call recordings will be kept according to VA policy; 100% recording and 100% retention”[1]. VA’s 2017 contract for the same service had required one[1]. In March 2023, the representative then overseeing the contract wrote that the 2019 security checklist “has been inaccurate since day 1”[1].

Staffing lagged too. The contractor’s plan called for 50 backup responders by October 2022 and 92 a month later[1]. It did not reach 50 until eight months after the planned date and never reached full staffing before VA ended the service[1]. A crisis line official told the inspector general that 60 responders would have been needed, about 10% of the roughly 600 VA responders who answered calls each month[1].

Who knew, and when

The inspector general put a date on it. Crisis line officials and the contracting officer’s representative knew about 1.5 months into the new subcontract, and the contracting officer about 3.5 months in, that the contractor could not comply until it met security standards[1]. At a Nov. 2, 2022, meeting, a crisis line deputy executive director said the contractor was at least one to two years from providing service, and the acquisition division chief raised the options of modifying the contract or issuing a 60-day stop-work order[1].

Neither happened. The contracting officer told the meeting that the contractor had to be given a chance to comply and had to be paid, and later told reviewers he had waited for direction from crisis line officials[1]. The crisis line’s deputy executive director said a backup was needed while VA’s internal system was still being finished[1]. The acquisition division chief told reviewers the contract file held no evidence that services were missing and that crisis line officials never sent formal written notice saying so[1].

In earlier interviews, the contracting officer had said the contractor should be paid during implementation but “not if they were invoicing for taking calls if they were not taking calls”[1]. The representative who approved the invoices said they were approved on the contracting officer’s advice that payment was justified under a fixed-price contract while the contractor worked toward approval[1]. VA’s acquisition manual says “the COR should not recommend invoice payment solely on the recommendation of another government employee,” the report noted[1].

On March 1, 2023, the crisis line’s executive director approved exercising another option year, and VA issued the modification on April 5[1]. By the end of April, VA had paid about $9.2 million for backup services not received[1]. In May 2023, crisis line leaders decided to end the backup services, and the contracting officer issued a termination memo June 28[1]. VA agreed to pay $677,575 in settlement costs, bringing the total paid for services not received to about $11.9 million; the inspector general left the settlement out of its $11.2 million questioned-cost figure[1].

Where VA and the inspector general differ

The inspector general made two recommendations, both addressed to VA’s Office of Acquisition, Logistics, and Construction[1]. On the first, consulting the Office of General Counsel on whether to file a claim to recover the $11.2 million under the Contract Disputes Act, Phillip W. Christy, the office’s principal executive director, concurred and set a target of Dec. 31, 2026[1].

On the second, a review of how VA decides security requirements before awarding contracts that involve sensitive data, VA concurred only in principle[1]. Its response acknowledged that “an error occurred” on the security checklist but said the acquisition team generally followed policy, and that “VA does not believe this issue reflects a systemic breakdown in enterprise acquisition or security governance processes”[1]. VA said it had reinforced the requirements with the team and asked that the recommendation be closed; the inspector general agreed to close it[1].

The report itself points to a gap that goes beyond one checklist: VA’s handbook does not require a second review of the security checklist before award, and the contractor’s required annual security self-assessment was not in the contract file[1]. The information security officer had not seen one and thought it was no longer required[1].

Outages are a separate federal concern. In a rule published Jan. 16, 2024, the Federal Communications Commission required phone carriers and companies that route 988 calls to report outages and to notify VA directly when an outage could affect the system[4]. In that proceeding, the crisis line pressed for reporting of outages shorter than 30 minutes, arguing that as many as three suicide deaths could occur in that window; the commission kept the 30-minute threshold, saying the record did not show a shorter one would strike a better balance[4].

What happens next for the crisis line?

The review grew out of an earlier inspector general report, issued Aug. 22, 2024, on the crisis line’s preparation for 988 press 1[1]. The inspector general noted that VA announced a reorganization of the Veterans Health Administration in December 2025 and that its effect on these problems is not yet known[1]. The recovery recommendation stays open until VA shows evidence it has acted[1].

If you’re affected

  • Reaching the crisis line: Dial 988 and press 1, text 838522, select “Chat” at veteranscrisisline.net, or call any VA medical center or community-based outpatient clinic and follow the instructions[1]. The line is open 24 hours a day to all veterans, regardless of enrollment in VA care or discharge status[1].
  • What the report covers: The findings concern payments and contract oversight from July 2022 through June 2023, not the crisis line’s own responders[1].
  • The report: The full review is posted at vaoig.gov under report No. 23-03464-146. The inspector general’s office lists (202) 461-4720 for questions about it[1].

Readers ask

Did VA pay for Veterans Crisis Line services it didn’t get?
Yes, according to VA’s inspector general, which found VA paid about $11.2 million from mid-July 2022 through June 2023 for contracted backup call responders who did not provide the service[1]. VA also paid $677,575 in settlement costs when it ended that part of the contract[1].
Will VA try to get the $11.2 million back?
VA agreed to consult its Office of General Counsel on whether to file a claim against the contractor under the Contract Disputes Act, with a target of Dec. 31, 2026, for that step[1]. Any claim is subject to the act’s statute of limitations[1].
Is the Veterans Crisis Line still working?
The report does not say the crisis line stopped answering calls; VA built its own internal backup system, which was minimally operational by May 2022[1]. Veterans can reach the line by dialing 988 and pressing 1, texting 838522 or using the chat at veteranscrisisline.net[1].
Does federal law require Veterans Crisis Line backup centers?
A 2016 law required VA to set performance measures for the crisis line, including at backup call centers, and to plan for every call, text and other message to be answered in a timely manner by a person[2].

Sources

  1. Review of Contracted Backup Services for the Veterans Crisis Line (Report No. 23-03464-146). VA Office of Inspector General, September 1, 2026.
  2. No Veterans Crisis Line Call Should Go Unanswered Act (Public Law 114-247). U.S. Government Publishing Office, November 28, 2016.
  3. National Suicide Hotline Designation Act of 2020 (Public Law 116-172). U.S. Government Publishing Office, October 17, 2020.
  4. Ensuring the Reliability and Resiliency of the 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline (FR Doc. 2024-00428, 89 FR 2503). Federal Register (Federal Communications Commission), January 16, 2024.

A note on sourcing

This report rests on the inspector general’s review, VA’s written response to it, and the laws and federal rule that govern the crisis line. The report does not name the contractor or either subcontractor, and none of them had posted a response on the inspector general’s site as of publication; the law gives named businesses a chance to do so. The report examines payments and contract oversight; it does not measure whether any veteran’s call went unanswered or was delayed because the backup center was idle, and this piece makes no such claim. The piece does not include reaction from members of the House or Senate Veterans’ Affairs Committees or from veterans service organizations. Whether VA will try to recover the money remained undecided; VA set Dec. 31, 2026, as its target for that decision.

Filed underVeterans Crisis Line · suicide prevention · VA inspector general · VA contracting · 988

Return to THE FRONT PAGE